Skip to main content
Community Building & Management·Lesson 3 of 5

Moderation & Guidelines

A community without moderation becomes a community nobody wants to be in. Clear guidelines and consistent enforcement create the psychological safety that members need to participate openly. This lesson covers how to build a moderation system that scales.

Writing Community Guidelines

Your community guidelines are the social contract. They set expectations for behavior and give moderators a framework for decisions. Write them before you launch.

Essential sections to include:

Purpose Statement

One paragraph explaining what the community is for and who it serves. Example: "This community exists for social media professionals to share strategies, ask questions, and support each other's growth. We welcome marketers of all experience levels."

Expected Behavior

Be specific about what good participation looks like:

  • Be respectful and constructive in all interactions
  • Stay on topic in designated channels
  • Share knowledge generously — help others when you can
  • Give credit when sharing someone else's work or ideas
  • Use content warnings for sensitive topics

Prohibited Behavior

Clearly state what is not allowed:

  • Harassment, discrimination, or hate speech of any kind
  • Spam, unsolicited self-promotion, or DM marketing
  • Sharing others' private information without consent
  • Deliberately misleading information
  • NSFW content (unless the community explicitly allows it in designated channels)

Self-Promotion Policy

This is the most common source of tension in communities. Be explicit:

  • "Share your own work in #showcase only"
  • "No cold DMs promoting services to other members"
  • "Helpful answers that happen to reference your product are fine; blatant ads are not"

Consequences

Outline what happens when rules are broken:

  1. First offense — warning via DM from a moderator with an explanation of the violation
  2. Second offense — temporary mute or timeout (24-72 hours)
  3. Third offense — permanent removal from the community
  4. Severe violations — immediate removal (harassment, hate speech, illegal activity)

Post your guidelines in a pinned #rules channel and link to them in the welcome message. Update them as new situations arise.

Moderation Tools

Discord Bots

Automated moderation saves time and catches issues when human moderators are offline:

  • MEE6 — auto-moderation (bad word filter, spam detection, caps lock filter), leveling system, custom commands, and welcome messages
  • Carl-bot — reaction roles, auto-moderation, logging (tracks deleted messages, edits, and joins), and custom triggers
  • Dyno — moderation commands (ban, kick, mute, warn), auto-moderation, and announcement scheduling
  • AutoMod (built-in) — Discord's native auto-moderation for keyword filtering, spam prevention, and mention limits

Configure auto-moderation to catch the obvious stuff (slurs, spam links, excessive caps) so human moderators can focus on nuanced situations.

Slack Tools

  • Slack's built-in moderation — channel-level permissions, message deletion, user deactivation
  • Workflow Builder — automate responses to common questions and flag messages with specific keywords
  • Third-party apps — tools like ChannelTools or custom Slack apps for more advanced moderation needs

Dealing with Conflict

Conflict is inevitable in any community. How you handle it defines your culture.

Low-Severity Conflicts (Disagreements)

When members disagree passionately but respectfully:

  • Do not intervene immediately — healthy debate is good for community engagement
  • Step in if the tone shifts from debating ideas to attacking people
  • Redirect: "Great discussion. Let's keep this focused on the topic rather than each other."

Medium-Severity Conflicts (Rule Violations)

When someone breaks a guideline:

  1. Address it promptly — within hours, not days
  2. DM the person privately first. Public callouts embarrass people and escalate situations.
  3. Be specific: "Your message in #general violated our self-promotion policy. Please keep promotional content to #showcase."
  4. Log the incident in your moderator channel for the team's awareness

High-Severity Conflicts (Harassment, Toxicity)

When someone is harassing, threatening, or being actively harmful:

  1. Remove the harmful content immediately
  2. Temporarily restrict the person's access while investigating
  3. Gather context — check message history and talk to involved parties
  4. Make a clear decision (warning, temp ban, or permanent removal) and communicate it to the person via DM
  5. If warranted, address the community without naming the individual: "We recently removed a member for violating our harassment policy. We take these guidelines seriously."

Scaling Moderation

As your community grows, you cannot moderate alone. Build a moderation team:

When to recruit moderators:

  • Your community has 100+ active members
  • You are spending more than 1 hour per day on moderation
  • Members in different time zones need coverage outside your hours

Choosing moderators: Look for members who are already helpful and active — they understand the community culture. Ideal moderator traits:

  • Active in the community for at least 1-3 months
  • Calm and fair in disagreements
  • Good written communication skills
  • Enough availability to check in daily

Training moderators:

  • Create a private moderator guide with common scenarios and recommended responses
  • Set up a private #mod-chat channel for discussing situations and making collaborative decisions
  • Do a shadow period where new moderators observe before taking action
  • Hold monthly check-ins to discuss challenges, update guidelines, and prevent burnout

Moderator burnout is real. Rotate responsibilities, recognize their contributions publicly, and give them the authority to take breaks when needed. Unpaid moderators who feel unappreciated will leave.